This Justice Cometh Substack (Host of Tracing Justice , Co Host of Fellowship in the Word , and Co Host of Real Justice) post has done extensive analysis at what appears to be funneling of over $2.8 Million to what appears to be a Shell company Information Cataloging Strategies owned by Presler and his partners.
Per Justice Cometh:
So in short 51.8% of all spendings of Scott Presler’s Early Vote Action Pac went to a company called Information Cataloging Strategies. Why That Doesn’t Add Up:
1. Single shell vendor doing everything
• Real PACs spread services: texting vendors, digital ad shops, fundraising consultants, mail houses.
• Here, one mysterious company allegedly did all of it — from building websites to running SMS blasts.
2. No corporate footprint
• Not registered in Vermont or Delaware.
• No website, no LinkedIn, no industry presence.
• $2.8M companies don’t operate in total silence.
3. Residential address
• The company is tied to a $1.9M home owned by Joseph Atencio, a private equity executive.
• High-end home, but no sign of a call center, ad team, or campaign infrastructure.
What It Likely Really Was
• Pass-through vendor: Funds routed in, then paid out to other firms or individuals, disguising the real recipients.
• Consultant laundering: Inflating invoices for “strategy” and “consulting” — classic bucket to siphon donor money.
• Dark-money funnel: PAC cash redirected into private or corporate networks with no transparency.
Plausible “Services” That Could Eat $2.8M
If it were real, here’s what $2.8M would typically buy in campaign terms:
• ~20 million peer-to-peer SMS messages to voters.
• Several statewide digital ad blitzes (YouTube, Facebook, programmatic display).
• National direct-mail fundraising campaigns.
• A professional call center and data operation.
Let’s look into the Information Cataloging Services website https://infocataloging.com/
That’s it. Two buttons. A client login button and a get in touch button. No “about us” or any mentions of any address. Nothing. That’s it.
None of that evidence exists. No public ad traces, no visible campaign infrastructure.
Bottom Line
“Information Cataloging Strategies” almost certainly wasn’t delivering $2.8M worth of campaign services. Instead, it looks like a phantom vendor used to launder EVA PAC’s money, parked at Atencio’s Vermont address for cover.